Yumdrinker101 on Aug 16, 2013 wrote:

Hey, I just finished the quest to promote ratbeard from commander to captain and in the quest you need to go after fowl because he is the one who poisoned ratbeards crew, why do we have to go after him? we already killed captain fowl back in the gullet before we even get ratbeard on my crew. This seems wrong, was he rezuurected????? thnx

I... don't recall ever killing Captain Fowl before. I don't think we've ever heard of a Captain Fowl before, till Ratbeard told us of him during that promotion...

Blind Mew on Aug 22, 2013 wrote:

If you do your side quests, you can meet Captain Fowl in the MooShu Falcon quest before Ratbeard's second promotion. But if you do them in this order, Ratbeard doesn't know about Fowl's link to his crew yet. Having trounced him once a while back isn't enough - the bird must pay. Again.

As to Fowl's recurrence, we build our stories on the certainty that our combats (despite any appearance to the contrary) are non-lethal. So people you defeat (especially interesting villain types) can come back. Given enough time, most of them will...

Even Nim and the Brass Monkey? It was thrilling to beat Nim once, but it's possible that he may come back again soon, still on the hunt for Marco Pollo's Map, and pursuing revenge against the PC for his defeat. I'm quite certain there are other yet to be seen villainous hunters who are also on the Map hunt may be brought up later on, because Nim's not alone in this. Besides, One-Eyed Jack said that every hunter in Skull Island's been hunting for the Map after word about it got out back then, and it's certain there's a lot of those hunters out there other than Nim.

And, having already beaten the Brass Monkey twice, once in Skull Island, the second time in MooShu, he still says he will have his vengeance. I'm certain a third encounter with him is inevitable, still bearing the burning thought of revenge in his heart and mind. And when he does return, I'm sure I'll be ready for him.

Seeing Captain Fowl twice and defeating him during Ratbeard's second promotion quest was fine, but I'm not sure if there's a third time seeing him... unless his cell in Fort Elena was busted open during it's crippling by the Armada's ship cannons and he would be free again to get revenge... but could it be possible? If so, I'll be ready for him!